Skip to content

The FTC fake review rule and what a Shopify store has to change

The FTC's Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule has been in force since October 21, 2024. Here is what it prohibits, what it can cost, and the specific settings, disclosures and habits to change in a Shopify store.

Industry · Nov 16, 2026 · 9 min read
Review authenticity
Verified buyer badge
No rating held back
Rewards for any honest review
Customer words never edited
K
Verified buyer
Published

What the FTC fake review rule bans

The FTC's Trade Regulation Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials was approved by the Commission in August 2024, according to the FTC's rulemaking page, and it took effect on October 21, 2024, per Goodwin's 2024 alert on the final rule. The ftc fake review rule reaches any Shopify store selling to US customers, not only large retailers: Hogan Lovells wrote in 2024 that companies selling goods and services to end customers, and the businesses that promote, market or otherwise assist them, should take note. Penalties are real money, and the FTC began sending warning letters under the rule in December 2025.

The FTC rule on fake reviews from 2024 largely codifies existing FTC policy and sets limits for six categories of conduct, as Goodwin's alert describes. The prohibitions that matter most to an ecommerce store are these.

  • Buying or selling reviews. Is buying fake reviews illegal? Under the rule it is a violation: the FTC's own questions and answers page explains that brokers of fake reviews generally fall under Section 465.2(a)'s prohibition against selling a consumer review.
  • Conditional incentivized reviews. Goodwin's 2024 alert states the final rule prohibits all conditional incentivized reviews, so a business cannot condition any compensation or benefit on the review expressing a particular sentiment, as Morgan Lewis describes it.
  • Undisclosed insider reviews. Goodwin notes it is a violation for an officer or manager to solicit or demand a review from immediate relatives or employees, and Morgan Lewis gives the example of a business disseminating a testimonial by one of its own officers or managers.
  • Company-controlled review websites. Goodwin's alert says the final rule prohibits companies from creating or controlling review websites or platforms presented as independent.
  • Review suppression. The final rule prohibits businesses from selectively suppressing negative reviews or otherwise manipulating what shoppers see, per Goodwin, and Morgan Lewis adds that it is also prohibited to misrepresent that select consumer reviews represent most or all reviews.
  • Fake indicators of social media influence. The rule prohibits the sale or distribution of fake indicators of social media influence, according to Goodwin.

One thing the rule does not cover: Goodwin notes the FTC declined to finalize the provision on review hijacking, meaning reviews taken from one product and repurposed for another. That is not a green light. The FTC's questions and answers page warns separately that using non-representative consumer reviews in marketing could be deceptive under Section 5 of the FTC Act.

Who enforces the rule and what the penalties are

The FTC enforces the rule directly and can seek civil penalties per violation. Morgan Lewis wrote in 2024 that the Commission would be empowered to impose penalties of up to $51,744 per rule violation, subject to annual inflation adjustment. Coverage of the agency's December 2025 warning letters reports that those letters warn of a federal lawsuit or other legal action and civil penalties of up to $53,088 per violation. Those are the ftc penalties for fake reviews a merchant should plan around.

Enforcement has started. The FTC announced in December 2025 that staff sent letters to 10 companies warning of potential violations of the Consumer Review Rule. DLA Piper's 2026 analysis reports that six letters went to property management companies, three to personal injury law firms and one to an accounting firm, and that the conduct was effectively the same across all ten: providing money or other incentives in exchange for reviews.

Liability is not limited to the brand. The National Law Review's guide notes that advertising agencies, public relations firms, review brokers and reputation management companies are potentially liable under the rule. On the software side, the FTC's questions and answers page says the rule's exemption for mere review hosting does apply to a business that solicits review submissions or aggregates star ratings, so the obligation to get the settings right sits with the merchant.

Review gating is the setting most stores need to fix

Review gating means asking every buyer how they feel, then inviting only the happy ones to post publicly while routing the unhappy ones to a private form. Is review gating illegal now? The rule prohibits selectively suppressing negative reviews or otherwise manipulating what gets shown, per Goodwin's 2024 alert, which puts classic gating squarely in scope.

Filtering is not banned outright. Hogan Lovells notes the final rule allows advertisers to filter or withhold some reviews so long as the criteria for doing so are applied equally to all reviews submitted. Morgan Lewis lists limited circumstances where withholding is contemplated, such as a review that contains trade secrets, privileged or confidential information, or the personal information of another individual, and adds that the provision also applies where a business reasonably believes a review is fake or wholly unrelated to the products or services offered.

The practical test for a Shopify store: whatever rule removes a review must be written down, must not mention the star rating, and must be applied to five-star reviews exactly as it is applied to one-star reviews.

Incentivized review requests and the disclosure they need

Incentivized reviews and FTC compliance come down to one distinction. Morgan Lewis gives the clean example: a business offering customers $5 off a future purchase in exchange for a product review is not inherently unlawful, and it becomes unlawful when the incentive is conditioned on the review expressing a particular sentiment. The FTC's questions and answers page addresses the obvious workaround and rejects it: a business cannot pay incentives for 5-star reviews on third-party platforms even if reviewers add a disclosure about the incentive.

Where a disclosure is needed, Keller and Heckman's 2024 analysis notes it must be clear and conspicuous, meaning easily noticeable and easily understandable by ordinary consumers. Two lines of copy do the job in a review request email and on the review form.

Every reviewer gets 100 points, whatever rating you give. Write what you actually think: we publish the one-star reviews too.

This review was written by a customer who received a reward for reviewing, offered to all buyers regardless of rating.

Shopify practices that now carry risk

Most Shopify stores are not buying reviews. The exposure sits in ordinary settings nobody has revisited since they were switched on.

PracticeWhere it stands
A survey step that sends 1 to 3 star buyers to a private formSelective suppression of negative reviews is prohibited
An app setting that holds reviews below 4 stars off the widgetFilter criteria must apply equally to all reviews submitted
Reward offered for any honest review, rating not mentionedPermitted; the $5-off example is not inherently unlawful
Reward or bonus promised for a 5-star reviewConditional incentivized reviews are prohibited
Founder, staff or family review posted as a customerInsider testimonials need disclosure
A homepage widget of hand-picked five-star quotesDo not imply select reviews represent most or all reviews
One product's reviews reused on an unrelated listingHijacking provision not finalized; Section 5 deception risk remains

Sources: Goodwin's 2024 alert on the final rule, Morgan Lewis (2024) and the FTC's questions and answers page, all linked above.

Deleting a bad review because it is bad is the single clearest violation in the list, and the alternative is cheap: answer it in public. Our guide to responding to negative reviews on Shopify covers the reply itself.

A compliance checklist to work through this week

  1. Open your reviews app settings and look for any auto-publish threshold, star filter or survey branch that treats low ratings differently from high ones. Turn it off.
  2. Write down the criteria you do use to remove a review: profanity, spam, personal information of another person, content unrelated to the product, reviews you reasonably believe are fake. Apply them to every rating.
  3. Rewrite reward campaigns so the incentive is offered for an honest review at any rating, and never for a positive one, and add a clear and conspicuous disclosure to the request and the published review.
  4. Audit your existing reviews for insider entries from staff, founders, friends or family, and either disclose the relationship on the review or remove it.
  5. Check that featured quotes, homepage carousels and ad creative do not imply that the selection represents all of your reviews.
  6. Keep a written review collection policy in a shared doc, dated, with the person responsible named, so you can show your process if it is ever questioned.
  7. Brief whoever runs email, ads or agency work for you, since the National Law Review notes agencies and reputation management firms carry potential liability too.

The policy can be one paragraph.

We request a review from every verified buyer after delivery. We publish every review we receive, at every rating. We remove a review only for profanity, spam, another person's personal data, content unrelated to the product, or where we reasonably believe it is fake, and these criteria are applied identically to all ratings. Rewards are offered for any honest review and are never conditioned on what the review says.

Publishing the negatives alongside the positives is now a compliance safeguard as well as a trust signal. It is also the pattern we see across customer stores that collect reviews at volume.

What to check in the reviews app itself

Whatever app you use, confirm three things: that it does not hide reviews by rating, that merchants cannot rewrite what a customer wrote, and that any AI moderation judges content rather than stars. The FTC's questions and answers page notes the rule does not impose a general duty for businesses to investigate whether each review of its products is fake, so the goal is a defensible process, not a forensic one.

Quoli is a Shopify product reviews app, and its Review Authenticity Policy sets the same lines the rule draws: the Verified buyer badge means the review came through a request Quoli sent for a recorded order, merchants cannot edit what customers wrote, rewards are offered for any honest review whatever the rating, and critical reviews may not be held back because of their rating. Quoli Intelligence includes a confidence check that screens reviews publishing on their own for abusive or offensive wording in any language, and it judges wording only, never the rating.

The pieces that keep a compliant program working are the ordinary ones: requests timed after delivery, reviews from verified buyers, public replies to the bad ones and attributes so shoppers can filter honestly rather than being shown a curated few. Quoli has a free forever plan, and paid plans start with a 14-day trial; pricing is here.

Frequently asked questions

Is it illegal to ask happy customers for reviews?

Asking for reviews is not banned. The problem is asking only the happy ones. Goodwin's 2024 alert notes the rule prohibits selectively suppressing negative reviews, so send the same request to every buyer and publish what comes back.

Can I still moderate reviews for spam and profanity?

Yes. Hogan Lovells notes the final rule allows filtering or withholding reviews so long as the criteria are applied equally to all reviews submitted, and Morgan Lewis lists circumstances such as another person's personal information, or a review the business reasonably believes is fake or wholly unrelated to the product.

What counts as an incentivized review?

Any review written in exchange for money, a discount, points, free product or another benefit. Morgan Lewis notes a $5-off offer in exchange for a review is not inherently unlawful; it becomes unlawful when the incentive depends on the review expressing a particular sentiment, and the FTC's Q&A says a disclosure does not cure paying for 5-star reviews.

Do product Q&A answers fall under this rule?

The sources describe the rule as covering consumer reviews and testimonials. An answer written by your team should be labeled as coming from the store, since Morgan Lewis notes the rule reaches testimonials disseminated by a company's own officers or managers without disclosure. Keeping staff answers clearly attributed in a product Q&A avoids the question entirely.

What should I do if I find an undisclosed employee or incentivized review?

Add a clear and conspicuous disclosure to it or take it down, then fix the process that produced it. Keller and Heckman notes disclosures must be easily noticeable and easily understandable by ordinary consumers.

Can the FTC fine a Shopify store directly?

Yes. Morgan Lewis put the penalty at up to $51,744 per violation in 2024, adjusted annually for inflation, and reporting on the FTC's December 2025 warning letters cites up to $53,088 per violation alongside the threat of a federal lawsuit.

Try Quoli on your store

Install Quoli free from the Shopify App Store. The free forever plan covers the core widgets, and paid plans start with a 14-day trial.

4.9/5 on the Shopify App Store

See Quoli on your store

Start on the free forever plan or book a demo with a product expert.